Blog · Industry news

Notefinder: A Sheet Music Store, Not a Maker

Former MuseScore Studio people have launched Notefinder, a licensed sheet music store with its own arrangers and a free iPad reader. What it changes for players and teachers, and what it does not.

Notefinder is a new digital sheet music publisher and store, announced by Scoring Notes on November 9 after a soft launch several weeks earlier. It sells professionally prepared arrangements through a subscription or as individual PDF purchases, read in a free iPad app. Behind it are several people who shaped MuseScore Studio: Daniel Ray, Jonathan Kehl, Martin Keary, Bradley Kunda, Simon Smith and Vasily Pereverzev, plus Tony Berman, Muse's former general counsel. The company says it employs around 40 people, most of them arrangers, spread across Europe with a substantial group in Latvia. It is operated by Real Music, Inc., and its editions carry the trading name "Music, Inc." It is not a sheet music maker in the software sense: there is no community upload catalog, and the catalog is licensed repertoire plus in-house arrangements.

Why this matters if you want a score out of a recording

Most people reading this arrive with a recording, not a title. You have a track, you want to know what the drummer actually played, or what the pianist voiced under the second verse, and you want it as notation you can edit and print. Notefinder does not do that. It sells an arrangement of a song, made by a person, reviewed by other people, and licensed for sale.

That is a different product from a transcription, and the difference is worth being precise about:

Published arrangement (Notefinder)Transcription of a recording
SourceThe song, interpreted by an arrangerOne specific performance
AnswersHow should this be playedWhat exactly was played
Editable fileNot described in the announcementPDF, MusicXML, MIDI
RightsLicensed and sold by the publisherA derivative work; rules differ by country

If a student needs to learn "Every Breath You Take" as a band, a prepared rock band arrangement with a full score, eight parts and a combined-guitar alternative is genuinely useful. Scoring Notes notes that Notefinder's version includes exactly that, so a band with one guitarist does not have to reconcile two separate guitar parts. That is an arranger making a decision on your behalf, and it is a good decision.

If you need to know what Andy Summers played on the record, note for note, the arrangement will not tell you. That is a transcription job.

What it changes in practice, and what it does not

The interesting part of the announcement is not the store. It is the production line. Arrangements are commissioned, assigned to an arranger with relevant instrumental knowledge (a guitarist takes the first pass at a rock song, keyboard and percussion specialists review their own material), then style-edited and reviewed. Reviewers' feedback is described as training as much as correction. The rock band arrangement is the starting point, and other editions are arranged down from it rather than produced by deleting staves.

That last point matters more than it sounds. Anyone who has pulled instruments out of a full score to make a piano reduction knows the result is technically complete and musically wrong: the left hand ends up playing a bass line written for a bass guitar, the voicings sit in the wrong register, the pedaling is nonsense. Notefinder says it is not doing that. Whether the piano/vocal/guitar editions hold up is a question only playing them will answer.

Three things it does not change:

  • Transposition is not available yet. The company is holding transposed versions back until it has a review process for the results. Scoring Notes quotes Martin Keary on why: moving every pitch by the same interval preserves the relationships between notes but can make a particular instrumental part less playable. If your singer needs the song down a whole step on Thursday, this catalog cannot help you yet.
  • Editable formats are not described. The announcement covers PDF purchases, a subscription and a free iPad reader. It says nothing about MusicXML or MIDI export. If you want to open the arrangement in MuseScore, Sibelius, Dorico or Finale and change the drum notation, ask before you buy. A PDF in an iPad reader is a reading tool, not an editing tool.
  • It does not replace your ear. A published arrangement is one person's editorial reading of a song. It is not the record. If the record is the reference, you still have to listen.

Our view

The launch is a licensing story wearing a software story's clothes. The names that will get attention are the notation people, but the hard part of a sheet music publisher is negotiating rights and paying advances, and the team includes people who have done that at Ultimate Guitar, MuseScore.com and as general counsel. The announcement also flags plans to improve the software used to make the scores and, eventually, to change what musicians can do with a score after they download it. That second part is the one to watch, and it is the one with no detail yet.

Where we are skeptical: a catalog built around search demand and one starting arrangement per song will be deep on popular repertoire and thin everywhere else. Teachers working from a method book, a choral director, or anyone who needs an obscure tune in a specific key will not find what they need for a while. The absence of transposition is a real gap for exactly the audience that buys the most sheet music: schools and worship teams, where the key is set by the singer, not the publisher.

Where it is clearly right: the market genuinely does have a dozen retailers selling the same solo piano edition of the same song and nothing for the ensemble in the room. A rock band chart with a combined-guitar part is a small thing that saves a rehearsal.

Who should care. Teachers and band leaders who buy arrangements: worth a look at the catalog for the songs you actually teach. Producers and transcribers: less so, unless the "what you can do with a score after you download it" plans turn into something concrete. Players learning parts off records: this is not your tool, and the announcement does not pretend it is.

One honest note on rights, because it comes up every time. A published arrangement is licensed. A transcription you make of a commercial recording is a derivative work, and whether you can hand it to a class, post it, or perform from it depends on your country and on the rights holder. Buying a PDF from a store and making your own transcription of the same song are governed by different rules. If you are unsure, ask the publisher or your local licensing body.

What to do next

If you want notation of a song as arranged for your ensemble, go and read the Notefinder catalog and check the edition details: instrumentation, difficulty, key, page count. Ask about file formats before you pay, especially if you plan to edit.

If you want notation of a recording, that is what we do. Upload a song, pick the instrument model (drums, piano, bass and guitar each have their own), and you get PDF, MusicXML and MIDI back. For a busy mix, run the stem splitter first: separating vocals, drums, bass and the rest is usually what makes a transcription of a full band usable. If you only need the notes as data for a DAW, the audio to MIDI converter skips notation entirely. The Explore library has transcriptions people have shared, which is a reasonable place to see what the output actually looks like before you commit. Developers can call the transcription API. Plans and what they include are on pricing.

And keep the expectation honest: automatic transcription is a first draft. Recording quality, how busy the mix is, the instrument, and whether you separated stems first all change the result. A musician still edits it. That is the job.

Sources

Pertanyaan yang sering diajukan

Is Notefinder a transcription tool?
No. Notefinder is a publisher and store. Its catalog is prepared by its own arrangers and by publishing partners, and there is no community upload catalog. If you have a recording and want notation of that specific performance, you need a transcription tool or a human transcriber.
Can I get a transposed version of a Notefinder arrangement?
Not yet. According to the announcement, transposed versions are being held back until the company has a review process for the results. If your singer needs a different key this week, that edition does not exist yet.
Does Notefinder replace buying from a traditional publisher?
It competes for some of the same customers and repertoire, and it also distributes editions from publishing partners. Whether a given song is available depends on what they have licensed and arranged. Check the catalog before assuming.
What formats does Notefinder deliver?
The announcement describes PDF purchases and a subscription, read in a free iPad app. It does not describe MusicXML or MIDI export. If you need an editable file for MuseScore, Sibelius, Dorico or Finale, ask before you buy.
How is this different from making my own transcription?
A published arrangement is someone else's editorial decisions about a song, licensed and sold. A transcription is a reading of one specific recording, which you then edit. They answer different questions: how should this song be played, versus what exactly did this player play.
Can I share or resell a Notefinder score?
That is a licensing question, not a technical one. Read the terms on the site and ask the publisher directly. Copyright rules differ by country, and buying a PDF is not the same as buying distribution rights.

Transkripsikan lagu

Unggah sebuah lagu dan dapatkan notasi yang bisa diedit. PDF, MusicXML, dan MIDI.